About Johnathan Shirey | Naples Luxury Real Estate

Johnathan Shirey

Primary phone
(239) 560-9340
Website
http://johnshirey.com
License Number
#3212563
Email
[email protected]
Address
1144 3rd St S,
Naples, FL 34102

About Johnathan

Originally from Canton, Ohio, Johnathan moved to Florida in 2003, beginning his career as an assistant to one of the country’s top agents before earning his own license and building a thriving business. Ranked as the #60 Agent by Volume in Naples in the 2025 RealTrends Verified rankings, Johnathan is recognized for his data-driven approach, forward-thinking strategies, and deep commitment to client education. A veteran Naples agent with more than 17 years of experience, Johnathan has built his career on understanding market cycles, analyzing monthly market statistics, and helping clients confidently navigate an ever-changing real estate landscape.

Johnathan’s philosophy is rooted in patience, active listening, and a client-first mindset. Known for his trusted monthly market reports, he provides clear, accurate insights while maintaining a calm, thoughtful presence throughout each transaction. Clients often describe him as a steady guide, never aggressive, always attentive, who makes the process smooth, informed, and enjoyable. His expertise spans downtown Naples, waterfront neighborhoods, and top country club communities, consistently placing him among the top 1% of agents in Naples, Florida, and nationwide.

With Johnathan, clients receive more than representation, they gain a knowledgeable advisor and dedicated partner committed to achieving their real estate goals.

When he’s not immersed in real estate, Johnathan enjoys spending time with his wife, working out, playing tennis, or traveling. A passionate skier, he frequents Aspen, Vail, and Jackson Hole, and visits international destinations. At home in North Naples, he also enjoys relaxing by the pool, spending time at the beach, and attending Porsche Club of America events.

Testimonials

Lynne R.

Without a doubt a great Realtor®. He is very knowledgeable, responsive, honest, and very helpful. I would have no objections to recommending him or using him again in the future.

Ronald N.

Johnathan was the one to find our dream home. Would highly recommend him for his knowledge of Real Estate in the area, his professionalism, and courteousness. Thank you, Johnathan.

Cheryl B.

Johnathan is very professional, honest, and knowledgeable. He was able to assist us from beginning to end always keeping our interests in mind. I really appreciated his attentiveness and his guidance in bringing us a happy expe...

Mark A.

My wife and I were looking for a nice condo in SW Florida with some upscale amenities like a clubhouse, watersports, restaurants, and indoor plumbing. Johnathan was patient and very knowledgeable about the local market and we w...

North S.

Johnathan is a conscientious and consummate professional. His local area knowledge is quite obviously comprehensive. His tireless energy in identifying and educating us about the proper areas for search, coupled with his exhaus...

Rose M.

Johnathan is an outstanding Realtor®. He was professional, knowledgeable in the housing market, and had an engaging personality. He was not pushy, but rather he was patient making sure we got the place we wanted. Johnathan was ...

Carolie M.

We put Johnathan to work - we visited the area a total of 4 times, lost on one offered by a few hours, and with his help, survived a complex negotiation complicated by some surprise information about the property not revealed i...

Kevin S.

Johnathan has been an outstanding, and very patient agent to work with. We have bought other houses in other states, and feel Johnathan is one of the best we have dealt with. It is a very odd time to be a buyer, since the curre...

Rick S.

I had a great experience with Johnathan. Unlike other Realtors®, that are focused not on their client's interests but on their own, he spent time with me to get to know the things important to me and understand my taste. He wil...

Peter S.

John went out of his way to help our family find the perfect home. He spent a great deal of time listening for key characteristics and seemingly dedicated his efforts to selecting home options that exceeded our expectations. ...

Jill L.

I have had the pleasure of working with Johnathan as a preferred partner, he is an extremely detailed realtor with his client's best interest always front and forward. He is proactive, negotiates at high levels. Johnathan is ...

Peter S.

John went out of his way to help our family find the perfect home. He spent a great deal of time listening for key characteristics and seemingly dedicated his efforts to selecting home options that exceeded our expectations. ...

Brek K.

Had an amazing experience with Jonathan in our search for the perfect Naples retirement property. We have been working with Jonathan for over a year looking at different communities in order to find the perfect fit. Jonathan...

Sushma G.

Johnathan is professional and is very helpful specially when you are staying in a different state. He was always available to go check out the site as needed, researching and providing names of different vendors, coordinating s...

Richard S.

We saw ourselves spending more time in Naples over the coming years and decided it was time to find a home/community our whole family could come down and enjoy. After explaining our needs, John narrowed down the top communities...

Kelly T

We have bought and sold many homes throughout the US along with in Florida and saying that our trust needs to be very well earned is an understatement. Without a doubt it was an absolute breath a fresh air to have Johnathan as ...

Elaine B

Johnathan, Congratulations to you on closing our deal on our condo. We are very appreciative that it was your expertise that directed us to put the property back on the market when we did. Thank you so very much, it was a pleas...

Paul B.

Johnathan, Congratulations to you on closing our deal on our condo. We are very appreciative that it was your expertise that directed us to put the property back on the market when we did. Thank you so very much, it was a pleas...

Lindsey B.

We recently purchased a home in Naples while living out of state, and we truly could not have done it without Jonathan Shirey. From start to finish—and even well beyond closing—Jonathan went above and beyond in every way. He m...

Meet Johnathan Shirey

Johnathan Shirey

About Johnathan